Friday , 12 January 2024

Violence & Non-Lethal Weapons

The arguments that have been circulating in opposition to non-lethal weapons have rung in terms of how-dangerous-non-lethal weapons-are. These arguments lack teeth. Is it not better to be tased than shot? The problem is that non-lethal weapons are not used in place of lethal ones. Non-lethal weapons are dangerous, but more than that, they multiply violence by incapacitating  subjects. Stephen Coleman in his TED talk: “The moral dangers of non-lethal weapons (NLW),” gives the first scientific argument that we have come across.

After the Vietnam War in 1975, Gerald Ford renounced the use of chemical weapons in the previous wars; not only herbicides like Agent Orange, but riot control agents as well. NLWs also include nightsticks which, theoretically, should only be used in place of lethal force. NLWs, in practice, are mostly used to incapacitate crowds and subjects, not in place of of lethal weapons.

The embedded video explores a lucid approach to the dangers of non-lethal force and the escalation of violence as a result. The overall point is that out of the 2k or so incidents of non-lethal force noted at a given time, it cannot be said that each time the use is warranted as an alternative to lethal force. Even American conservatives agree that riot control agents violate international law.

“Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld acknowledged in Congressional testimony the other day, the use of riot-control agents and other substances designed to incapacitate people without causing death or lasting injury violates international law – specifically, the 1993 Chemical Weapons Convention.”

http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/0214/p02s01-usmi.html

NLWs, in local police setting, are supposed to be used in place of a lethal weapon. If the wielder would find him or herself in a situation where lethal force could be replaced by non-lethal force, this would warrant legitimate use. NLWs have been shown to multiply violence by incapacitating  subjects, making them easier to control, easier to commit violence against.

The  improper use of NLWs has been evident in the sea of viral videos of people getting tased including adolescent children and bedridden grandmothers. Yes, grandmothers. One has to wonder whether the escalation of NLWs is due to access and novelty, rather than utility, and enforcement. With the growing use of NLWs it is important to discuss ethics openly. We believe that Stephen Coleman does that well.

From TED:

About karololesiak

Karol Olesiak is a poet, writer, and activist. He is a graduate of Eugene Lang Liberal Arts College at The New School and an MFA from The University of San Francisco. As a Navy sailor, he commissioned the USS Ronald Reagan, navigated the straits of Magellan, and served in the Persian Gulf. In 2011 Karol headlined The Bowery Poetry Club in New York. That same year he became a staunch supporter of The Occupy Wall Street Movement and became entrenched in the Occupy network of affinity groups. Karol was one of the founders of www.soldiersforthecause.org. He became an antiwar activist in 2010 and has written many political essays. He has been translated into Spanish. Karol's poetry has been incorporated into cinematography and sound art.

Check Also

#SFTC Statement on Ukrainian Crisis

We here at #SFTC decry war in any form and therefore in response to the …

Reckoning of the Hacker Martyr

It’s been over a week since the announcement that Julian Assange will be extradited to …

Why Net Zero is Blah Blah Blah

“I’d like to see the government get out of war altogether and leave the whole …

Exclusive: USS Ronald Reagan UAP Encounter

This article is a departure from our usual content. Most of the founders of #SFTC …

Defund VA Police

Activist veteran organizations need to look at VA Police. More than half of minority vets …

Vanessa Guillen: MST Martyr?

Vanessa Guillen was bludgeoned with a hammer, on base, in the armory, her remains were removed in a box. Several people saw, now deceased due to suicide, Aaron Robinson struggling with the box the night Vanessa disappeared. Guillen was a private and Robinson was a specialist. They both worked in the armory but in the army that small rank difference means a lot, and many, (if not most) exploit that.

Juneteenth, Warren Court & Trans Lives

Warren’s leadership and influence over the other judges lead to a subversion of the Jim Crow South. The zeitgeist of minority rights against majority oppression was institutionalized irreversibly by the Warren Court.

Prison Abolition in the Age of Coronavirus

In the Prison Abolition Movement, it is a well-known fact that Police have a shared history with Slave Catching. There was a need to capture runaway slaves in metropolitan areas before that there was no need for police. Most of the lynchings of Jim Crow South were well attended and represented by police and how enforcement is distributed today is reflection of that history. Too many police and prison guards are former military to ignore the link to the prison industrial complex.

Radicalisation

On the history of radicalization in the Western context. It can be argued that Saul …

Fake News

In 2012 I wrote an entry about Julian Assange and Russia Today (RT). At the …

Watch: The King of Stolen Valor

Oki’s Weird Stories finally made a documentary that’s relevant to us. The youtube channel has …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.